運動生理學網站 會員:未登錄 登入 忘記密碼 申請加入會員  會員9982  部落格5  




主題:請問何謂柺杖效應
發言 : 阿亮 時間 : 06/03/23(23:09:48) From : 218.171.181.243
請問一下:何謂柺杖效應,我找好久都沒看到!麻煩一下!謝謝!


回應 : 8 櫻婷時間 : 2006/3/27 下午 10:11:58 From : 220.142.92.229

林老師不是說不要指定回答嗎?
呵呵,其實這題我也不會寫,
而且大學的時候上運動生理學也沒上到!(還是我太混阿?!)
上次會回答,只是因為看到有人在生理學討論區問心理學問題,
感覺有點奇怪!所以就講一下這不是生理學範圍內的東西!
guidance effect.....
不過我猜可能是跟輔導效果有關的吧!
至於為什麼叫做"柺杖"效應...是不是跟音譯有關呢?!


回應 : 9 櫻婷時間 : 2006/3/27 下午 10:31:42 From : 220.142.92.229

恩...我很認真的去找了一下,
終於發現以下這段文字:
『....認為導引練習僅為表現變項的學者曾將導引練習比擬為柺杖,
有導引練習時,就好像有柺杖支撐在走路,當柺杖一拿開,就失去支撐,
也無法移動了.為了避免導引練習真的形成柺杖效應,在適當提供導引練習後,還是應該讓學習者嘗試獨自練習....』
所以「柺杖效應」應該是說:因為沒讓學習者獨自練習,而產生學習者只要沒有導引就無法做出動作。
這個應該比較符合運動心理學的解釋吧!呵呵!


回應 : 10 scwang時間 : 2006/3/30 下午 10:15:18 From : 140.123.226.99

Support for an explanation of the guidance effect in motor skill learning
J Mot Behav. 2005 May;37(3):231-8. Related Articles, Links
Anderson DI, Magill RA, Sekiya H, Ryan G.
Department of Kinesiology, San Francisco State University, 1600 Holloway Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94132-4161, USA. danders@sfsu.edu
The authors investigated whether the knowledge of results (KR) schedule influences the extent to which intrinsic feedback is noticed and used. Fifty-six participants received KR that was either delayed over 2 trials (Delay-2) or provided directly after each trial (Delay-0) during 160 trials of an unfamiliar aiming task. No-KR retention tests were given after 80 trials and 1 min and 24 hr after the end of acquisition. After retention, all participants were questioned about their use of intrinsic feedback during practice and whether those sources changed as a function of practice. The Delay-2 group performed significantly less accurately on the 1st and last blocks of acquisition trials but showed a significantly smaller performance decline from acquisition to retention. Moreover, the Delay-2 group noticed and used a greater variety of intrinsic feedback sources and its members were more likely to report that their usage changed with practice.



共有 10 回應   回上頁   發表回應
 B 吤芠z М
 B 吤芠z М     リげ] B V m
 B 吤芠z М    x W   a V m A ��  x
 B 吤芠z М      Z w   P V m B
    (PFQ) [ c
 B 吤芠z М    C 皉~    蚺  R
 B 吤芠z М   YouTube W D
健康運動的方法與保健

運動與健康

 j M     瓴ルZ

運動生理學網站粉絲團
運動科學教育研究室